South West Florida Real Estate News-North Port-Port Charlotte-Venice-Englewood-Punta Gorda

head_left_image

Waste of Paper

I was talking to a potential seller the other night, and she was telling me about the various agents she had interviewed without mentioning any names. One, she said even brought her a 30 page book of comps for her property. She was really impressed.
The property is in a more rural area but on a moderately priced golf course, so I guess you could say it's a golf course community. No gates or high priced fees, just overlooks a golf course.  Only one property has sold out there in the past year, and it wasn't a really close comp for the house. I did find others on the same street for sale and similar enough to give us some idea of a price.
What I can't figure is what a book of 30 pages filled with comps from golf course communities as far away as 30 miles would have to do with the true value of this property. The agent said she just wanted them to see what was out there in golf course communities since there were no close comps. I can see no real importance to these comps since the other communities are much more upscale and so far away.
A couple of appraisers told me they try to stay within a mile of the property and within a few years of the age and a couple hundred square feet of the size. They said that they use a little more leeway on larger, newer homes than older, really small ones.
I think giving someone a booklet of comps that are not even in the same town is practically meaningless. I can see a few miles since this is a more rural area, maybe even within the same city, but 20-30 miles away in other towns? What a waste of paper.
Comment balloon 6 commentsShannon Moore • September 30 2006 04:49PM

Comments

Its amazing you could find 30 pages of comps in today's market. I look in one square mile from the subject and use comps that are very simalar
Posted by Bob Pavey, CRS (RE/MAX Hometown) almost 12 years ago

What a waste of time.  If the seller was impressed with that charade, they'll probably list with the other agent. 

The wisest thing to do with that property is hope the other agent gets the listing and then go in for a second presentation when the listing expires and the owner is interviewing again.

Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, http://www.homefinders.com.  Serving home buyers in Maryland and Virginia

Posted by Lenn Harley, Real Estate Broker - Virginia & Maryland (Lenn Harley, Homefinders.com, MD & VA Homes and Real Estate) almost 12 years ago
THE OTHER AGENT OBVIOUSLY DIDN'T KNOW WHAT THEY WERE DOING. YES, WHAT A WASTE OF TIME & PAPER.
Posted by Susan Milner, Cape Coral Real Estate Broker, FloridaFutureAgents (Florida Future Realty, Inc.) almost 12 years ago

30 pages of comps, as far away as 30 miles.......that's pretty funny.

<a href="http://naples.condodomain.com/register.php">new naples condos</a>

Posted by new condos almost 12 years ago

We wish you a merry Christmas! We wish you a merry Christmas! We wish you a merry Christmas And a happy New Year! Glad tidings we bring To you and your kin! Glad tidings for Christmas And a happy New Year!

Broker Bryant and The Lovely Wife (pretend we are singing it works better like that) ROAR!

Posted by "The Lovely Wife" (Broker Bryantnulls Wife) The One And Only TLW. (President-Tutas Towne Realty, Inc.) over 11 years ago
Think of all those poor little trees! LOL! Sorry, couldn't resist!
Posted by Edith Wharton, Realtor - Chesterfield VA (Cottage and Loft Realty) over 11 years ago

Participate